Bringing the Past to the Future
One of the greatest resources that most New England towns of any size and located near water have are the former mill buildings of the textile industry. Since the domestic textile manufacturers have fallen victim to overseas competition, millions of square feet of facilities sit idle and, in many cases, deteriorating. In this paper, I will discuss reuse of "mill construction" for high tech information technology purposes, specifically data centers, and the features that make this type of facility ideally suited for this use.
Industry statistics point to a large growth in demand for data center space. Many existing data centers are constrained by their building infrastructure in ways that former mill complexes are not.
Definition:
The mill facilities I discuss here are classified as type 4 buildings (heavy timber or "mill construction"). This type of building is characterized by a thick brick shell (usually 4-5 bricks thick) with heavy timbers secured through the brick to support the internal floors. Floor construction is usually 5-6 inches of tongue and groove plank with hardwood on top. Roof construction is tongue and groove plank overlaid by asphalt and gravel or rubber membrane.
Structural
The equipment involved in data center services is typically extremely heavy and trends indicate that this is only going to increase. Cabinets, racks, equipment of higher and higher densities, AC power equipment, DC power equipment and batteries, large and large cooling systems, the weight involved can overwhelm even the most modern of type 1 constructed buildings.
In contrast, mills tend to be vastly over-engineered in terms of structural strength (this presumes that the building has no deterioration issues from neglect). The massive timber supports combined with the thick floors produces a structure that will hold even the heaviest of equipment gracefully, deflecting under the most extreme loads rather than failing catastrophically as some cement floored modern buildings have been prone to do. Note that floors that exhibit issues such as sagging, excessive unevenness, or even movement should be thoroughly examined for integrity before applying equipment loads.
The ease of working with the mill flooring also negates the need for raised floors. This reduces the floor loading (raised floor is extremely heavy), cost, and ancillary expenses (raised floor requires an underfloor fire suppression system, for example). This also improves the quality of the facility as well (no raised floors removes one of the worst causes of equipment failure in the data center, metal whiskers). It's also very easy to coat the hardwood flooring to reduce static electricity, a major requirement for working with electronic equipment.
The integrity of the mill roof is of critical importance. Roof leakage can lead to floor damage, roof structure damage, or damage to data center contents or power facilities.
Power:
Many current data centers are in the unenviable position of having to severely limit the amount of available power per sq ft of space. This has come about because these facilities were not designed with the increasing densities of equipment in mind. This leads to running out of power capacity long before available floor space is exhausted.
Former mills, on the other hand, tend to be equipped with massive amounts of power. On the negative side, not all power types typically found in the mills can be applied without extra equipment.
Typical power encountered is 208Y120, 240D, 480D, and 480Y277 VAC. 240D and 480 were normally used for 3 phase machinery and are not generally useful in the data center without the use of transformers to convert to 208Y120. A notable exception to this are some of the largest DC power plants that use 480 directly.
Fire Suppression:
Fire suppression requirements for a mill based data center are similar to those found in other building types. A well engineered and functional sprinkler system, inert gas system, fire and smoke detection, and alarm system are all appropriate.
Cooling:
Many mills tend to be relatively low structures with vast amounts of flat or nearly flat roof space. This makes it far easier to install cooling systems since the data center is much closer to the roof. Mills also tend to be poorly insulated which is actually a benefit in this case, since even in the coldest of weather, the data center will generally produce enough waste heat to require removing it, rather than heating the space.
Alternative Power:
The large amounts of nearly flat roof space available on the average mill is ideal for alternative forms of power. Wind and solar generation can reduce the operating cost of the data center dramatically. As well as improving the data center operating margin, this allows the data center to claim the designation of environmentally friendly.
Summary:
Communities everywhere are searching for ways to use the vast brick monoliths that were once their economic engines. Millions of sq ft of space sit idle in many of these communities and it has far more potential than it's original manufacturing duty.
Even across all the intervening years, it's easy to see that these mills were the high tech of their time and they are still uniquely suited to serving the high tech of our time.
Labels: Bringing the Past to the Future
